Digital Consensus? Opportunities and Risks of AI & Co.
Digitalization isn’t just omnipresent in daily life; at the IEC GM’s Consensus Day in Hamburg, the topic also dominated the discussions from the first to the last agenda item. After all, the principle of consensus itself is not up for debate in the standards community—but the path to achieving it certainly is. Both the IEC’s opening event in the morning and the closing panel in the evening addressed this question: How can new technologies change the process of consensus-building in a way that ensures consensus does not lose its value? What is the significance of different cultural viewpoints and the industry’s perspective?
Of course, no definitive answers were found, but it was clear from the participants that it is precisely these answers that will pave the way to the future. One thing became clear in Hamburg: Consensus-based, modern standardization requires digitalization - whose potential is evident, for example, in the SMART Standards campaign, which was presented at a separate event. However, the necessary adjustments to standardization processes also require consensus, as some countries are able to implement such initiatives quickly, while others need more time.
The importance of AI in standardization was also discussed at length, with a focus on the balance between trustworthiness and efficiency. There was no dispute among the panel or the audience that AI - a technology that is itself the subject of comprehensive standardization initiatives - can generate the minutes of meetings or translate documents. Consensus-building itself, however, was attributed more to human intelligence than to artificial intelligence. Gilles Thonet, Deputy Secretary-General of the IEC, reflected on the role of AI in standards development: “AI can significantly improve the efficiency of standards development by supporting tasks such as summarizing meetings, drafting documents, checking contents for consistency, and translation. However, international consensus is built on trust, discussion and sound judgement. These remain fundamentally human qualities that are essential to the standards development process.”